A 60% eval at scoping is a no with an eval number and a re-test date, unless a harness change moves it.
The case, the two scorecard lines, and why the fourth column belongs to the lab are in Two Months, Then One Day: OpenAI Published the FDE Scorecard. The handshake's three columns come from In the Room, Not on the Quota: Who Owns the FDE Promise. The probe to run before calling a gap a model gap is in Which Model Is the Smallest Knob in the Architecture Review.